15
Councillor Sarah Whitelock, Cabinet Member with responsibility for Communities, Culture, Leisure and Tourism introduced report ES/2595 which related to Supporting Cultural Events in East Suffolk
The report had two distinct parts, one focussed on financial support for the First Light Festival (FLF) and the other on wider events and cultural activity support via the extension of the cultural strategy delivery budget, practical events support and the cultural lead role. Regarding the FLF, Councillor Whitelock stated that the report demonstrated that the culture and the arts were supporting the delivery of the Council’s ‘Our Direction 28’ priorities across multiple themes including economic, communities and environment.
The current 3-year funding agreement with FLF had expired and the recommendation was to provide a new 3-year extension at the same rate as previously support of £500,000 which would match fund the Arts Council’s significant investment.
To secure FLF beyond the Local Government Review (LGR), the proposal included a budget line for FLF until 2034/35. Whilst future successor Councils could be held to this, having an allocation within the base budget could mean its future inclusion was more likely.
FLF has delivered tremendous outcomes for Lowestoft and East Suffolk since its inception, these included:
- over 200,000 people attending (approximately 40,000 a year)
- 1000’s of artists and creatives taking part
- 640 volunteer hours
- over 4100 local organisations involved including all the town’s schools
- showcasing Lowestoft as a vibrant and diverse cultural centre which has resulted in a large amount of national and regional media coverage
- supports the wider cultural and leisure led Lowestoft regeneration programme
- addressing deprivation and providing opportunities to engage with the local labour market
Regarding other events in East Suffolk the paper also dealt with an extension of the cultural strategy delivery budget, events support funding and Cultural Lead role. It was due to expire in 27/28 and currently provides £54,000 a year to support delivery of East Suffolk’s Cultural Strategy.
It was recommended that this funding was extended to 2034/35 to provide resilience and support to cultural sector beyond LGR.
It was recommended that the Cultural Lead role which was due to expire in February 2027 was extended until March 2028 so East Suffolk Council (ESC) had capacity to deliver the cultural strategy up until LGR. Councillor Whitelock concluded that it was also recommended to extend the practical events support budget which ESC provides funding for elements such as barriers, additional cleansing and temporary toilets.
Councillor Smith queried the figures provided. The Chair stated the correct figure in recommendation one, should be £450,000 and it looked as though there was a typographical error on the report. Councillor Smith added that it would be helpful for members to understand what the total additional money on top of the £450,000 would be - to cover the period up to 2030.
Councillor Wilson responded that in supporting papers under section 4.4 in table 3 it showed a total of £480,000 across four areas. The Chair clarified that the total was £480,000 of which £450,000 was going to be utilised for the delivery of the First Light Festival.
The was further discussion regarding confusion over the total amount being proposed. Councillor Willson confirmed the entire budget was £480,000. Councillor Whitelock added further information from 4.1 of the report. Councillor Smith confirmed she was looking for the total amount of funding the Council was committing to up to 2035.
The Chief Executive confirmed that the current approved budget was £780,000 which was highlighted in the table Councillor Wilson referenced (table 3 at 4.4). A supplementary £480,000 was being requested to that figure.
Councillor Jepson queried the amount of funding that First Light Festival contributed themselves to events and referenced that originally the introduction of the festival was done so with the intention that it would start to be less reliant on council funding. Councillor Jepson was disappointed that the figures provided in the report were not clear. Councillor Whitelock responded that the contribution was evident particularly to those who attend the festival. Councillor Whitelock was happy to provide further detail on the financial contributions from First Light.
There was a discussion regarding a motion to defer the item of business until there was clarity on the figures. The Chair confirmed there was no possibility to defer, there could be a motion without notice to refer to a committee or a motion to withdraw, which the proposer and seconder would need to agree. There could be a motion to amend.
Councillor Whitelock added that First Light Festival do not directly contribute any funding. East Suffolk Council has kept funding the same and not increased with inflation. First Light Festival had increased costs which needed to be met.
Councillor Folley added that events in Felixstowe did not get similar funding that First Light do. The annual Carnival raises its own sponsorship and funding, which annually achieves approximately a million pound for the town. Councillor Folley stated she could not support the recommendations. Councillor Folley recommended the item be referred to the Audit and Governance Committee. The Chair responded that it would not be a matter for Audit and Governance Committee to consider and did not accept the motion to refer.
Councillor Graham stated that the Arts Council changed its strategy which brought attention to areas of cultural inequalities by providing community events on the streets which were free for communities to experience. Councillor Graham highlighted that being a community interest company allowed them to borrow money to make certain decisions, and it was a not-for-profit organisation, who invest into the festival. They continue to do work to bring money in, including work at East Point Pavillion. It would not be self-sustaining and to be effective it needed public bodies to step up and support. FLF had grown from year to year and gained national media coverage for its amazing work. It needed further investment to continue growth and support the need for growing security and rising inflation costs. Councillor Graham concluded that the festival was part of the overall regeneration project for Lowestoft.
Councillor Byatt stated that absolute clarity was needed on the figures being requested.
Councillor Wilson drew members attention back to the report under section 4.4, table 3. It was split into four budget areas, each of which had current approved budget lines. The first was for First Light Festival at £450,000 which had been in the budget for some time. The second was cultural strategy development which was £162,000. The third had an approved budget of £70,000 and the fourth £102,000. Which added to £784,000. The paper presented supplementary spending which added up to £480,000 which was being asked for. Councillor Wilson echoed other members thoughts on the festival being self-sustaining and highlighted that it was not the type of event that would be able to completely. FLF were working hard to look at ways to increase their incomes streams.
Councillor Smith echoed that she was supportive of the FLF, but wanted to understand the commitment for ten years, which was £1,264,000. The Councillor felt that the report could have been presented a simpler way for members to understand. Councillor Smith sought clarification that; FLF had been supported since 2019 and in total had £780,000 committed, which was 38.9% of the total is has raised, which was £2million.
Councillor Smith questioned why the report did not plainly state that the Council would be committing £1,264,000 for the next ten years and that the business would be robust to operate in the next ten years. Councillor Wilson responded that the request was for five years with the MTFS and the cost of the festival was £2million per year.
Councillor Smithson stated that it would be good to understand what FLF was doing to try to make itself more self-sufficient. Councillor Whitelock responded that the festival was working to achieve more income through camping pitches and food vendors as two examples.
Councillor Gooch highlighted the multiplier effect of the festival, which was a free event drawing visitors into the community who would spend money locally when there. The Councillor considered other festivals and events and was there a way to extend the multiple effect further.
Councillor King declared an interest as the volunteer at the festival since it started. The Councillor highlighted that it was a Community Interest Company (CIC) for trading reasons and it was easier to hold money as a CIC than a charity. Councillor King added that the town had experienced a loss of events in the past and the FLF was so important for the town.
Councillor Lynch stated he would not be able to support the recommendation and felt the report was poor. The Councillor had looked up the CIC and could see there was a £450,000 declared in their latest accounts and queried what the organisation was doing with that money.
Councillor Daly added that the organisation needed to plan for the next festival and the organisation needed to have funding available to work on the upcoming festival. The Councillor highlighted the benefits of the festival and the need for the money generated going back into the organisation for the next festival. It was there to add social value.
Councillor Jepson added that it would have been useful to have clearer figures presented to Full Council and clarified that his group supported the First Light Festival.
Councillor Deacon queried if the item was deferred the item would it jeopardised next year’s festival. Councillor Whitelock responded that the paper was not just concerning FLF but included other events. The Councillor did not think it could be made any clearer by coming back to a future Full Council meeting.
Councillor Ewart discussed transport issues which would present barriers to young people attending from local areas outside of Lowestoft. Councillor Plummer believed there were various transport options available for people to access the festival.
The Leader, highlighted the number of festivals that had been cancelled or postponed due to rising costs and lack of funding. The Leader urged members to support the paper.
Councillor Langdon-Morris thanked members for the detailed debate. It was a budget request which could be revisited and had been discussed with the Chief Finance Officer. The request formed approximately 0.2% of the total budget for the next five years.
Councillor Whitelock concluded that there was a shared desire for young people of the district to be able to enjoy the festival and access transport to attend. The Councillor confirmed that FLF needed to have money in the bank to pay for planning the next Festival. Councillor Whitelock echoed the positive comments made for the benefits of the festival.
On the proposition of Councillor Whitelock seconded by Councillor Graham it was by majority vote
RESOLVED
That Full Council:
1. Approved the use of the £450k allocated within the MTFS to support the delivery of FLF over the period 25/26 – 28/29 inclusive.
2. Approved a supplementary revenue budget of £150k for the MTFS period 2025/26 to 2027/28 to support the delivery of the FLF and ensure that the new 3 year funding agreement for FLF is at the same level of the previous agreement i.e. £500k
3. Approved an extension to the budget to support the delivery of FLF of £100k pa between 2028/29 to 2034/35, which equates to £700k, and includes a supplementary revenue budget requirement of £100k for the MTFS period in 2029/30.
4. Approved an extension of seven years for the existing Cultural Strategy delivery budget from 2028/29 until 2034/35, which equates to £378k, and includes a supplementary revenue budget requirement of £108k for the MTFS period in 2028/29 to 2029/30.
5. Approved an extension of the budget that provides practical support for events on ESC land of £40k pa from 2026/27 to 2034/35, which equates to £360k, and includes a supplementary revenue budget requirement of £160k for the MTFS period in 2026/27 to 2029/30.
6. Approved a supplementary revenue budget of £68k in 2027/28 for the extension of the Cultural Development Lead’s contract from February 2027 until March 2028 to ensure there is officer capacity to deliver the East Suffolk Cultural Strategy up to LGR and support the development and delivery of cultural events across the district.