8
The Committee received report ES/1089 of the Leader of the Council. The Head of Legal and Democratic Services introduced the report which aimed to address a number of procedural issues which had arisen at Full Council and provide additional detail on areas which Democratic Services were frequently asked about. In order to ensure consistency on how motions and questions were received and managed, it was proposed that templates and word limits be introduced for both questions and motions. This would also ensure that the purpose of questions and motions were clear, and debate could be followed by the public.
The Head of Legal and Democratic Services confirmed that the Constitution required a procedural debate ahead of the substantive debate in order to determine the most appropriate place for a motion to be heard. The Constitution stated that group leaders should meet ahead of Full Council to discuss this matter, but this had not happened thus far. It was felt that if this meeting could be introduced and group leaders could come to a consensus on where motions should be debated this would ensure better use of time at Full Council meetings.
It was also proposed that flow charts be introduced into the Constitution to make the process for motions clearer for members, officers and the public, and that the reading aloud of questions and motions be introduced into the procedure rules. This had been introduced during the Covid pandemic and was felt to aid openness and transparency.
Lastly it was proposed that the Committee Procedure Rules concerning the recording of votes be amended to bring them in line with the Council Procedure Rules.
The Chairman invited questions.
Councillor Byatt stated that there had often been confusion around motions and asked if appendices containing the background information for motions could be introduced to ensure all information was available whilst keeping the main motion shorter. The Head of Legal and Democratic Services responded that motions should be calls to action and if appendices were added in there was a danger that motions would become reports which had not been scoped by officers.
The Chairman commented that all members should be able to ask questions, and that members had adapted well to changes which had been made necessary due to Covid. He felt that the suggested amendments were a good starting point for confirming some of these changes, and asked that this be reviewed in a years’ time, at the end of this Council’s term, as changes to the format of meetings were still ongoing.
It was agreed that an additional recommendation be added to ensure that the Council Procedure Rules would be reviewed in 2023 at the start of the new Council term.
There being no further questions, on the proposal of Councillor Cloke and seconded by Councillor Richardson it was by a unanimous vote
RESOLVED
1. That the Audit and Governance Committee recommend that Full Council instruct the Monitoring Officer to amend the Council Procedure Rules in the Constitution:
a. To require members to submit their questions to Democratic Services on the Question template form and to limit member’s written questions to no more than 100 words
b. To require members to submit their motions to Democratic Services on the Motions template form and to limit member’s written motions to no more than 250 words
c. To incorporate Appendices B, C, D and E of this report into East Suffolk Council’s Constitution
2. That the Audit and Governance Committee recommend that Full Council instruct the Monitoring Officer to convene a meeting of the Chairman and the group leaders to discuss, and seek to agree, the venue for each submitted motion for Council after the deadline for motions to be submitted for Full Council has passed and before the date of the meeting of Full Council, pursuant to CPR 11.4.
3. That the Audit and Governance Committee recommend that Full Council instruct the Monitoring Officer to incorporate the motions and report flowcharts (Appendices C and D) into the Council Procedure Rules in the Constitution.
4. That the Audit and Governance Committee recommend that Full Council instruct the Monitoring Officer to amend the Council Procedure Rules to require members to read their questions and motions out aloud at Full Council.
5. That the Audit and Governance Committee recommend that Full Council instruct the Monitoring Officer to amend paragraph 11 of the Committee Procedure Rules to require that at least half the members of a committee present need to request a recorded vote for there to be a recorded vote.
6. That the Audit and Governance Committee review the changes to the Council Procedure Rules at the start of the new Council term in 2023.